And He looked up and saw the rich putting their gifts into the treasury. And He saw a poor widow putting in two small copper coins. And He said, “Truly I say to you, this poor widow put in more than all, for they all out of their surplus put into the offering. But she out of her poverty put in all that she had to live on.” Luke 21:1-4
All that she had to live on? What kind of retirement planning is that? Doesn’t she know that she will be a burden on those around her? Surely even those two copper coins could have been invested, perhaps combined with microfinance, to grow into something more substantial. Or even if spent for her own support, didn’t she owe to others contributing to her support the resources she had, meager as they were?
As a widow, with no social security, no safety net, these two copper coins were it. This was the bottom of the barrel.
These contributions were freewill gifts. They were not tithes or taxes. They were not obligatory. No one was required to put in anything at all.
I struggle with this. I worry about the future. Will there be enough? Will I stay healthy long enough to work and earn to save enough for years when I cannot work? And so I am selfish. I would never have put in those two copper coins.
What was she thinking?
She was thinking she lived in in open system, not a closed one.
A closed system is one where it is just us, and it is all up to us. An open system is one where God, who by His divine nature is not domesticated in our world and is not us, but created and loves us, speaks, moves and intervenes, beyond our human power and limitations into our world.
Doubtful the widow would have framed it in these terms. But she understood that her source, her supply, her future was not solely up to her. Her provision was not up to what she knew about, could see or could control. She knew, understood and trusted that God who had sustained her all these years would continue to do so. Her future was not up to her own resources or self-sufficiency.
Closed system thinking leads to selfishness, worry, anxiety and hoarding. It’s not just that we are inclined toward self-gratification and indulgence. Closed system thinking is that where one believes the only resources will be human ones. We are in charge. We are masters of our destiny. In a closed system the thinking leads to desperation, manipulation and striving for control.
Closed system thinking trusts only our own human resources. Open system thinking trusts God.
We are not in a closed system, where it is all up to us. We are not alone. We are not isolated.
The widow understood that in an open system, what makes it open is that God steps into it. He intervenes. He sees. He acts. Because He loves. Not a sparrow falls to the ground without His notice. Every hair on our heads is numbered.
God has a record. It is a record of faithfulness, abundant provision and generosity. We have His record in our own personal lives, the lives around us, and throughout human history recorded in scripture. The fact that sometimes we think God did not intervene in the way or timing we think He should have puts us in judgment of God. Trust me: we do not have the full information or status to make such judgments. God’s enormous record of unspeakable generosity, faithfulness and provision stands unassailable.
And so she gave a gift. It was all that she had to live on. She could do so because she understood that while those two copper coins where all of what she possessed to live on, it was not all of Who she possessed to depend on, or more accurately, Who possessed her.
She is reminiscent of Anna, the widow whose husband had died 7 years after they were married, and she then lived at least to the age of 84, never leaving the temple, serving night and day with fastings and prayers. At that advanced age she had the remarkable privilege of being present when the Christ Child was dedicated in the temple and prophesying over him. Perhaps Jesus had been told that narrative from His infancy and had Anna in mind as he saw this widow put in her two copper coins. These were two women who had their priorities right, their thinking right, and their trust in the right place.
Or perhaps Jesus was thinking of Hagar. Hagar had served as surrogate mother to bear Abraham’s son, Ishmael. Twice she was alone in the wilderness without provision facing certain death. The first time she fled from Sarah’s hostility. The second time, this time with her teenage son, she was dispatched and abandoned. As a single mother in that culture she had no status, no provision and no future. She suffered abuse from Sarah, and Abraham failed to protect or provide for her. Hagar had closed system thinking. With no provision, she expected twice to die. But God opened her eyes to see His intervention and provision.
Or perhaps Jesus was thinking of the widow and her son encountered by Elijah, who experienced God’s sufficient provision through times of famine. Or of Joseph through whom God prophetically spoke to store up during good years, and then had abundance to share during lean years.
May He open our eyes, my eyes, especially in times of great need, to see His ready provision. Rather than hoard, may we trust.
It is in trusting that the door is open for us to be freely generous, not just with the surplus, but right down to those last few meager crumbs we have to live on. Because we know with God we need not fear reaching the bottom of the barrel. Our provision is not limited to the barrel. He fills. He refills. He overflows. Our cup overflows. He sets before us His banquet table.
And so we can trust. And so we can be generous.
We can open our hand and stop tightly gripping the little we have. We can open our hand, give, release, and place our hand in His hand.
That is what she was thinking.
May I possess her thinking.
~~~
There are a lot of things we do in our walk with The Lord that could be seen by others as irresponsibility. Not just in the area of finances.. However for many our finances become one of the hardest things to relinquish control of. The idea of working hard to earn something, building, storing, making wise choices, and then “throwing it all to the wind”, should The Lord ask, seems incredibly irresponsible and out right silly. I mean, what about living by faith? What about sacrificing to build an ark years before a drop of rain? What about putting your son on an altar to be slaughtered and at the last minute having him be spared? These moments are for me are “glory moments” where the miracles of God are found. Count me in with open hands Lord! Ask me to give the impossible, the unthinkable! Ask me to go and do the impossible! Beyond rationality! and let me find you faithful in all your glory!!! Don’t pass me by to look for someone else to do the job. Ask me Lord!!! And by the strength your grace provides I will do it! I pray that the faith that woman had is forever planted in who I am that I would never close my hands to The Lord as long as I live..
Perceptive comments, as always, Jim.
Jesus also spoke much on our responsibility to be good stewards with His resources, to mind the store until His return. An essential lesson for another day. You are correct; we sometimes see examples of irresponsibility in the name of piety. Responsibility includes response ability, which implies wise management of resources.
That is not my risk. Miserliness is. What captivates me about this woman is her freedom to give, which can only come from trusting God for her future. The contrast this sets up for me is, will I steward resources allotted to me in a way that expects and anticipates God’s provision and active participation in human affairs, or with a deistic or atheistic perspective that has no such expectation.
The dichotomy is not between giving and and retaining. Retaining, with trusting, as wise stewardship for the purpose of later giving and serving, is still giving. The dichotomy is between trusting and self sufficiency. Trusting frees giving. Trusting should not be an excuse for irresponsibility.
Thanks for commenting!
Thanks Duane,
Provocative and skillfully written. It is a struggle because even as one reflects on our experience as Christians and reads about the action of God in history (recorded in the scriptures as you point out), in most cases, we humans are the agents of His actions. As agents of His actions, we manage resources. God doesn’t necessarily need me to spread the great news of Jesus – there are plenty of others. But if He has called me to do that, I will probably need at least the resource of health and energy to either do it myself and/or persuade others to contribute. Even your favorite model of managerial excellence – Nehemiah – could not have rebulit the walls of the sacred city without rocks!
We have even in our times instances of people being persuaded of Jesus imminent return, giving everything away and waiting expectantly. St Paul seems to have chided the Thessalonians for denuding themselves of resources in order to await Jesus return.
I don’t want to labor the point, but in most cases, we are His hands and feet, so His purposes are better achieved when we take the talents, work out how to multiply them, and them reuse them for the building of the kingdom, if if part of that building process is to care for ourselves and those of whom God has entrusted us with familial relationships.
I daren’t diminish the piety if the woman Jesus describes in the Lucan story, but I think that you and I might struggle to find the godly, practical balance on this matter is the inevitable consequence of our living in the world even though we may not be of it.
A lot more can be said on this issue, clearly, but I don’t need to hog the channel.
Blessings,
Jim